[adam_m]

I'm going to attempt to automate a lathe and wanted some user input and experiences on what electronics I should use.

I currently use a G540 on my CNC and have found it very reliable but I'm struggling with the parallel port connectivity and that its for 4 axis, 2 un-needed. I'm also design unaware, meaning the G540 is nice package in that I just need to connect the servo's to the unit, power it and go. With steppers and drivers it's a little more complicated.. I think the setup is a Motion controller, BOB?, steppers, drivers and power source... is a BOB needed???

I'd like to be able to use my laptop (Windows) and I would probably shy away from Linux.

So, my questions are in no certain order...

- Does it make sense to go G540 again and use UC100 to interface to my laptop?
- Is it cheaper to simply go with 2 steppers and drivers and an inexpensive BOB?
- If going the 2 steppers and driver route, are there suggestions for good reliable inexpensive equipment? I'm not looking for top dollar just reliability. I have Keeling motors on my current machine and have no issue with them, are there alternatives?
- What Motion Controller should I be looking at? Warp9, UC300, K flop, etc.?
- Reliability and ease of use, recommendations?

Appreciate any input...

Adam,

[adam_m]

Please delete this thread...

thanks,

[mactec54]

I'm going to attempt to automate a lathe and wanted some user input and experiences on what electronics I should use.

I currently use a G540 on my CNC and have found it very reliable but I'm struggling with the parallel port connectivity and that its for 4 axis, 2 un-needed. I'm also design unaware, meaning the G540 is nice package in that I just need to connect the servo's to the unit, power it and go. With steppers and drivers it's a little more complicated.. I think the setup is a Motion controller, BOB?, steppers, drivers and power source... is a BOB needed???

I'd like to be able to use my laptop (Windows) and I would probably shy away from Linux.

So, my questions are in no certain order...

- Does it make sense to go G540 again and use UC100 to interface to my laptop?
- Is it cheaper to simply go with 2 steppers and drivers and an inexpensive BOB?
- If going the 2 steppers and driver route, are there suggestions for good reliable inexpensive equipment? I'm not looking for top dollar just reliability. I have Keeling motors on my current machine and have no issue with them, are there alternatives?
- What Motion Controller should I be looking at? Warp9, UC300, K flop, etc.?
- Reliability and ease of use, recommendations?

Appreciate any input...

Adam,

A G540 may be a bit much seeing you only need 2 Axis for the Lathe, you still could use Gecko drives though, there are many good Stepper Drives also Leadshine make a good stepper Drive.

If you already are using a UC100 then that is your motion controller, all you need then is the software Mach3, a Breakout Board and a Stepper Driver to suit the steppers you are going to use plus Power supplies

I would use the Acorn Control which has a good lathe software package, UCCNC does not have CNC Lathe software and Mach3 Lathe software is not that great.