Concrete(standard) is generally regarded as poor material for machine tools,
compared to other materials.Reasons given include:a Poor Strength To Weight Ratio,its
dimensionally unstable(eg absorbs water),never really cures,Poor Strength compared to
alternatives,has virtually no tensile strength,is susceptible to cracking(lowering
strength),brittleness and its properties deteriorate over time.There may be damping
advantages from the use of concrete.I am only aware of around a handful of efforts to use
concrete in machine tools.
https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article...4_1_1/_article
Concrete Machine Tool Structures - Hand Tools - Concrete Construction
For a comparison of machine tool materials see page 136 of this pdf.
DSpace@MIT : Manufacturing and testing of composite machine tool structures
Remember to that a tube is much more structurally efficient than a bar of the
same material and this is not reflected in a direct comparison of material properties
alone,multiplying the strength advantage of steel.
For info on concrete(strength) variations see.
Types of concrete - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(There are perhaps 3 commercial machine tool builders using essentially uhpc,~= to
epoxy granite in specification,pc in the above pdf)
On beam design see these.
Reinforced concrete - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Basic Issues of Beam Design - Yahoo! Voices - voices.yahoo.com
Breaking a Plain Concrete Beam - Yahoo! Voices - voices.yahoo.com
Deflections of an Uncracked Reinforced Concrete Beam - Yahoo! Voices - voices.yahoo.com
Apart from the possibility of beam failure,I see the biggest problem being the concrete gantry being
to heavy.If its significantly heavier than say a steel alternative then you
will require heavier duty screws,rails,bearing etc and that will surely cost more than you
save by using concrete.If it was me I would use the steel in the gantry and table and use
the concrete in 6 or 8 pyramid shaped legs.
As an alternative consider there are many apparently successful builds in
steel including the mechmate and it is the material of choice for industrial router
builders(normalized I would think).This one looks good to me.
http://www.cnczone.com/forums/diy-cn...ext_cnc-6.html