584,814 active members*
5,227 visitors online*
Register for free
Login
IndustryArena Forum > MetalWorking Machines > Shopmaster/Shoptask > Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)
Page 1 of 2 12
Results 1 to 20 of 28
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    You can see more thermal pictures in the general Mill-Turn thread, but my spindle is really noisy and runs much hotter then it should. I've also got some build quality concerns because the mounting face of it was messed up by the factory in order to 'tram' the spindle and the access hole for the pin is too small to actually do any adjustments.


    I reached out to the guys who did the "how to build a CNC from scratch" thread, SkyFireCNC about getting a little higher quality spindle made. Their R8-80 spindle was almost the same size as the unit in the Mill-Turn and it comes standard setup for 6k rpm with optional 10k rpm bearings/balancing. It uses double angular contact bearings top and bottom instead of the single bearings in my Mill-Yurn. They also use an HTD style timing belt on their spindles, so I've requested a matching pulley for the stock motor with a 2:1 ratio. Right now my machine struggles/surges to reach the advertised 5k rpm (at the spindle) which is right at the ~120Hz/3600rpm upper limit @ the motor. The new 2:1 ratio should move the max rpm up to ~7k rpm without much of a drop in low-speed torque and with the timing belt, tensioning shouldn't be as finicky. I think it should fit between a 114-116 tooth 25mm wide HTD(5mm) belt.

    I've also designed up a simple mounting system for SkyFIre's power-drawbar (QTC system) which I believe is compatible with the real Tormach (TTS) system. I'll be releasing my adapter design files on Thingiverse. It's already been published and licensed under the Creative-Commons-Non-Commercial-Share-alike terms.

    Let me know if you're interested in participating in a group buy, there's already at least a couple others.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Your spindle should have double angular contact bearings on top and bottom. My machine reaches about max temperature within a few minutes of running, then pretty much stays at that temperature for as long as it goes. I don't have a gauge, but I can hold my hand on it no problem. If yours is noisy and getting hot like your picture, then my guess is you have a bad bearing. Shopmaster has a 3 year warranty on parts, so I think all the units out there should still be covered. Another fellow posted about upgrading from grease filled to oil filled bearings for high rpm work. They are pretty pricey at near 300.00 each, but may be worthwhile in the long term. Grinding on the cartridge is not the proper way to tram- using shims is fast and easy, and JT has a nice file on how to do it. A note of caution on the tooth belt drives- I converted one of my earlier machines to tooth belts and it was easy to do, but they are very sensitive to alignment. A V belt can take misalignment and work fine, but a tooth belt just a bit off will want to walk off the pulley and wear the belt, plus it will make an ear-splitting whining noise at high rpm, a sound that will drive anyone nuts. I am really interested in that PDB unit as well, so PM me with the price and some specs. Your drawing doesn't show the detail, but to work properly, it cannot simply put downward pressure on the drawbar, it must support the drawbar upwards at the same time, or the pressure will destroy the top bearing in no time. The overall concept looks like an easy fit on the machine with only a little sheet metal cutout necessary to clear.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    I'm aware my spindle is defective and improperly trammed by the factory, but the last time I sent something to Shopmaster for repair, it was some broken wires in the DRO and it took a full month for me to get it back, I think the lead time for a new spindle is only a bit longer and the current spindle should hopefully last that long.. I haven't taken my spindle apart, but the Norton_BMW guy did and his weren't double angular contact bearings and the part numbers he sent me match what I can read on mine.

    You bring up a good point 'tho, there seems to be plenty of deviations batch-to-batch with the Mill-Turns, so I'll post all my drawings so people can confirm whether this will fit their machines. This is not something I have any financial interest in, so I don't want anyone trying to hold me accountable if this doesn't work for them. That being said, if anyone needs the adapter mounts machined, I can probably make extras on our Tormach.

    We've got a Tormach PCNC 1100 with the power-drawbar at work now with the TTS system and it's just a ram pushing down on the bolt when actuated the same as SkyFire uses on their own machines. There might be a better method, but this seems to be working for a lot of people.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Hmm- very strange, the numbers he quoted in his post are classed as Double row angular contact bearings, and the picture certainly looks a lot thicker than a single row bearing. Maybe you need to open your spindle up to be sure. I would like to see a picture of your Tormach PDB, because there has been a lot of discussion on their forum from guys designing their own, and it's universally agreed that direct downward pressure on the drawbar is a death knell for the top bearings.

    Here is a link to a guy who documented the construction of a PDB for a Tormach.
    Experience with the Tormach Milling Machine and Power Draw Bar

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by BIGBLOCK1965 View Post
    I would like to see a picture of your Tormach PDB,
    Attachment 333562
    Let me know if you want any specific shots of it. It sure beats wrenching to change the bits constantly.. With the Mill-Turn it always seems like the sheet metal is in the way when it's time to change bits and it's so slow moving up and down, but I'm working on that problem as well.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by n1tr0 View Post
    Attachment 333562
    Let me know if you want any specific shots of it. It sure beats wrenching to change the bits constantly..
    Well it sure is putting pressure right on the end of the drawbar and the top bearing. Building one like that would be a snap, as those other styles require a lot more moving parts and extra machining. If it has been working fine for your Tormach, then maybe those other guys are just doing some of that engineering hand-wringing. So what you will be building is a mounting adapter for the Mill Turn, and then we would just buy the Tormach PDB- correct?

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by BIGBLOCK1965 View Post
    So what you will be building is a mounting adapter for the Mill Turn, and then we would just buy the Tormach PDB- correct?
    I've designed up an adjustable mounting system for the SkyFIre QTC system which is very similar to the Tormach unit, but it's about $300 instead of $1200... I'll be posting the design for public/non-commercial use for anyone who would like to copy it for their Mill-Turn. If anyone can't machine it themselves, they're welcome to contact me via PM and we can work something out.
    The 10k spindle was also very well priced as was the custom/matching motor pulley. I'd contact Skyfire directly and talk to Defeng as the pricing on the custom parts was even better than their published prices.
    It'll probably be fairly late tonight before I can post up drawings and such.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    [QUOTE=n1tr0;1938028] I sent in the DRO and it took a month for me to get it back,

    Sorry, I missed this bit on last response. I had an intermittent problem on my DRO as well, it would work fine, then sometimes one axis would blink off. After trying a lot of tests, we could not figure it out so JT asked me to send it back so his CNC guy could check it out. It arrived at his shop just as the CNC guy went on vacation, and he said he tried it on his machine and it was working fine. Just to save time, he sent me the unit off his machine. I had it back in a few days and put it on, all was fine and then BINGO, same problem. Finally I monkeyed around with the cable from the reader and found one of the pins was slightly bent. I straightened it out and since then it has been fine. But I found a nice surprise, the new display is the upgraded version with the Lathe-Mill display swap. As I'm sure you know, the axes designations are different on lathe and mill, which is not a big problem for manual work, but with CNC, it is confusing. On the mill X axis is longitudinal and is Z in lathe, while the Y mill axis cross slide becomes X in lathe and the Z in mill becomes Y in lathe. Trying to keep all this straight while reading the display and setting zero can be really confusing. The new displays are redesigned so that all you do is push a button and the readings from the scales will go to the proper axis in either lathe or mill mode.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Here's the pdf/drawing of the spindle I have on order from Skyfire. I've requested a 30 tooth pulley instead of the 36 tho so I can pair it with a 60 tooth motor pulley for my ideal rpm range. The motor pulley will have flanges to keep the belt from walking and I plan to sandwich a thin optical encoder disk between the spindle pulley and the locknut.
    Attachment 333640

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by n1tr0 View Post
    Here's the pdf/drawing of the spindle I have on order from Skyfire. I've requested a 30 tooth pulley instead of the 36 tho so I can pair it with a 60 tooth motor pulley for my ideal rpm range. The motor pulley will have flanges to keep the belt from walking and I plan to sandwich a thin optical encoder disk between the spindle pulley and the locknut.
    Attachment 333640
    Interesting, it looks like an identical cartridge to the Shopmaster, right down to the mounting holes- it should bolt right in place. My guess is that this is an off the shelf Chinese design from a spindle factory and the Shopmaster factory probably buys them there as well. The only difference I see is that the Skyfire uses unsealed bearings with the seals installed in the cartridge- do they run grease or oil bath? The flanges on the pulleys will prevent the belts from walking off, but unless the alignment is spot-on, you will get wear on the belt edge and that irritating whining sound, especially at 7500 rpm.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by BIGBLOCK1965 View Post
    Interesting, it looks like an identical cartridge to the Shopmaster, right down to the mounting holes- it should bolt right in place. My guess is that this is an off the shelf Chinese design from a spindle factory and the Shopmaster factory probably buys them there as well. The only difference I see is that the Skyfire uses unsealed bearings with the seals installed in the cartridge- do they run grease or oil bath? The flanges on the pulleys will prevent the belts from walking off, but unless the alignment is spot-on, you will get wear on the belt edge and that irritating whining sound, especially at 7500 rpm.
    It's actually a slight modification of Skyfire's R8-80 spindle that's been designed as a drop-in replacement for the Mill-Turn spindle using external measurements I took off my defective spindle. I asked them to include the flats on the face of the spindle so it can be tightened/loosened with a wrench so the PDB/QTC isn't required.

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by n1tr0 View Post
    It's actually a slight modification of Skyfire's R8-80 spindle that's been designed as a drop-in replacement for the Mill-Turn spindle using external measurements I took off my spindle. I asked them to include the flats on the face of the spindle so it can be tightened/loosened with a wrench so the PDB/QTC isn't required.
    That would be a great upgrade for mill turn owners- having a 10,000 rpm spindle available off the shelf that would bolt right in. Swapping out the spindle only takes a few minutes, so it could even be a way to change back and forth from the heavier milling to high speed operations. What is the price for the spindle?

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by BIGBLOCK1965 View Post
    That would be a great upgrade for mill turn owners- having a 10,000 rpm spindle available off the shelf that would bolt right in. Swapping out the spindle only takes a few minutes, so it could even be a way to change back and forth from the heavier milling to high speed operations. What is the price for the spindle?
    I was quoted $520 for the spindle and another $25 for the motor pulley + shipping... I don't know if I'm getting a break on pricing or if pricing may go down with more people, but I do know it's a small fraction of the cost compared to some other vendors I talked to.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by n1tr0 View Post
    I was quoted $520 for the spindle and another $25 for the motor pulley + shipping... I don't know if I'm getting a break on pricing or if pricing may go down with more people, but I do know it's a small fraction of the cost compared to some other vendors I talked to.
    That sounds pretty reasonable considering those high grade P2 oil filled bearings are near 300.00 each. I'm guessing they probably use the same P4 grade as Shopmaster, but maybe oiled instead of greased. Some of those production machine spindles cost more than the whole Shopmaster machine. I'm looking forward to seeing some pics when you get it installed.
    BTW- I found this video on You Tube- I thought it might have been your project since you said you were running a small end mill.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by BIGBLOCK1965 View Post
    BTW- I found this video on You Tube- I thought it might have been your project since you said you were running a small end mill.
    :stickpoke
    really? you thought that promo video from Shopmaster was my machine? The machine I received was a defective pile of crap. If it worked half that well I wouldn't have to be pouring thousands into making it work halfway decent.

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by n1tr0 View Post
    You thought that video was my machine?
    Yeah, from your posts about running at 10K RPM, it looked like that kind of a job, and since you are upgrading to the power drawbar , I figured it must have been a pretty complex program with a lot of tool changes.

  17. #17
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    77

    POWER DRAWBAR FOR MILL TURN

    There was some discussion on another thread about adapting a power drawbar to the Mill Turn, and people often ask us if we offer that as an option. We actually built an air butterfly PDB many years ago on our Bridgemill model and it worked great. However back then, there was not as much CNC work as there is now, so we have sort of revived the idea and our factory is working on some ideas for the future. There are as many designs out there as there are machinists, but not too many off the shelf units available. They come in 2 basic types-
    1. Air cylinder which compresses a drawbar with a stack of belleville washers to release tension on the collet.
    2. The air "butterfly" wrench which loosens and tightens the drawbar threads.
    Each has its own advantages and disadvantages.

    The compressing air cylinder design is more complex because it has to have a floating design to compress the belleville washers while not putting pressure on the spindle bearings. The air cylinders, valve and air fittings are available, but it takes some engineering calculations to get the proper cylinder etc. And the parts will be more expensive than the butterfly type. However, once engineered it will be a faster and lower maintenance setup. You can buy an off the shelf unit like a Tormach and adapt it to the Mill Turn, but you are looking at 1200.00, which is pretty pricey, considering you could source the parts and make all the components yourself for a few hundred dollars. Here is a simple drawing of how the Tormach unit might look on the Mill Turn.
    Attachment 333720 simple idea to attach the Tormach unit

    Attachment 333726 Tormach style with belleville washers

    Attachment 333728 The Tormach full kit

    The butterfly air wrench design is very inexpensive- there are some units on E-bay for 130.00, and one can be built for around 50.00 in parts. The concept is simple, in that the air wrench tightens and loosens the drawbar and with some calculations, it will force the collet down as the drawbar moves up and bottoms out in the socket. Some designs have a lever that you can use to pop the collet loose. However, you will need a better quality drawbar,as the threads are being loosened and tightened a lot. Eventually, the thread on the drawbar and the collet will begin to wear and need replacing. Here are some pictures of variuos styles and a link to a how to build thread.
    Attachment 333722 E-Bay unit for 130.00

    Attachment 333724 DIY design for 50.00

    Here's the link for DIY units
    CNC Cookbook: Powered Drawbar for IH Mill

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85
    Quote Originally Posted by BIGBLOCK1965 View Post
    Yeah, from your posts about running at 10K RPM, it looked like that kind of a job, and since you are upgrading to the power drawbar , I figured it must have been a pretty complex program with a lot of tool changes.
    You should read through my posts again. As delivered new from shopmaster my Mill-Turn couldn't (still can't) actually run at the advertised 5k rpm for two reasons. The pulley combination it came with puts 5k just beyond the motors max rpm (apparently changed the spindle pulley on some machines) and my spindle reaches 160f at anything over 3k rpm.

    The machine doesn't have the rigidity to just use big end mills at the lower rims and it doesn't have the x-y-z speed to do hsm tool paths, so the easiest upgrade is to increase the spindle speed for smaller bits.

    The idea with the custom Skyfire spindle is to raise the gearing to make 7k an honest, achievable max rpm. Fitted with bearings rated in excess of the max rpm, even if the 10k bearings are relatively cheap, they shouldn't be cooking themselves to death at 3k or 5k or even 7k.

  19. #19
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    85

    Re: POWER DRAWBAR FOR MILL TURN

    If you're going to take my pictures and drawings, it would be nice if you could get the information correct. This would be better posted in the existing thread.

  20. #20
    Join Date
    Aug 2016
    Posts
    61

    Re: Fix for Noisy/Hot Mill-Turn Spindle (& other upgrades)

    Quote Originally Posted by n1tr0 View Post
    You should read through my posts again.
    The idea with the custom Skyfire spindle is to raise the gearing to make 7k achievable max rpm.
    Meant no offense, quite the opposite- I thought the little note pad/pencil holder was a neat project with the engraved name on it. It must have taken some hours to hog out the metal, and then use that tiny end mill for the engraving. The final finish was nice, probably requiring a full climb mill around the entire surface.
    Bearing heat is caused not so much by friction of the balls and races, but by the contact of the seals. The Shopmaster bearings are double sealed, so you have 4 contact points. The Skyfire spindle uses unsealed bearings with external seals contacting the spindle which has a smaller diameter, so the overall seal friction of the Skyfire is probably about 25% of the Shopmaster. So even if they use the same grade bearings, they can achieve much higher RPM without excess heat. The only drawback is that eventually the top bearing on the Skyfire will lose its grease due to heat and gravity and require servicing.
    Here is a link to a really informative post all about bearings, rpm, friction etc.
    Ball Bearing Primer - VintageMachinery.org Knowledge Base (Wiki)

Page 1 of 2 12

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 04-01-2016, 07:55 PM
  2. MILL TURN UPGRADES
    By smallblock in forum Shopmaster/Shoptask
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 02-03-2016, 08:23 PM
  3. Replies: 2
    Last Post: 12-21-2015, 11:31 PM
  4. how to turn on spindle while mill spindle is on!!
    By the mill kid in forum Mazak, Mitsubishi, Mazatrol
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 11-22-2010, 08:08 PM
  5. Cnc Masters or Any chinese mill spindle bearing upgrades
    By m8kingit in forum Knee Vertical Mills
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 10-20-2009, 01:04 AM

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •