So,
In my current project, I'm sourcing parts for a 2000mm tall Z axis. I'm leaning towards a pulley belt drive based on a 25mm wide HTD8M Synchronous Belt. But I also saw some reasonably priced 20mm Ball screws in 2 meter length. (see attached jpg)
I don't need really fast speeds. I will be driving this with a Nema 34 Closed loop encoder stepper (8 N.m) driving a worm gear drive. (I haven't determined the gear ratio yet).
My thought is the worm gear reduction can't be back driven, so it will aid in holding the vertical position.
I'm leaning towards the belt, because It would allow me to adjust the Z height if my design needs.
The motion will mostly travel from the bottom up in apprx 1" increments. I don't really need sub mm accuracy.
What would be the pro's and cons going with Belt Vs. Ball Screw?
I think the 25mm HTD8M Synchronous Belt should be robust enough.
Also, I was thinking I could counterbalance if I go with the belt. Less work for the motor drive?
Thanks for any advice.
Randy