Hi rpseguin
We went though this last year in another post so you have not moved
to far on your project here it is again
Position Control this type of control moves the load from one known FIXED
POSITION ! (STOP) to another known FIXED POSITION ! (STOP) You Could
drill holes this way
Velocity / Speed Control moves the load CONTINUOUSLY for a certain time
interval or moves the load from one place to another at a precribed
Velocity / Speed ( SMOOTH & FAST ) ( The answer lies here
CONTINUOUSLY )
Torque Control measures the current applied to a motor with a known torque coefficient in order to develop a known constant torque
Used more for spindles than X / Y / Z motion
Your mouse you use on your computer is Position Control
Injection molding machine use Position Control
and many other machines and robots etc
No modern CNC machines Lathes / Mills use Position Control or Step / Dir to
control the motion
Most good mills all have Digital Drives today mine do with fiber-optic cables
to the control I build them like this myself
The Yaskawa Drives SGDH which you have or talked about & Legend SGDG Servo Amplifiers have all-Digital Architecture with 32-Bit control and have
been around for about 10 years or more
And the answer to your question Velocity / Speed verses Position
Try and do 3 or 4 axes in Synchronous operation or 3 axes Interpolation
in Postion Control it will not be easy to achieve or very smooth
Velocity / Speed Control is Plug & Play one machine I built 4 axes only had
( 2 ) Parameters to change in the SGDH Yaskawa Drives and that was for Velocity / Speed Control & AutoTune we have run it like this for 5 years with no change
__________________
Mactec54