That $500 may be a decent deal depending on how much you financed it for. Did you get the 1100? If so, that is probably double what I paid for the Torus. I think it was between 7 and 8 thousand delivered. I pay about $300 a year in insurance.

Here is the company that has my policy for the Torus and now the same policy on the Pulsar.
Great American Insurance Group - Welcome - Property Casualty | Annuities

They should be able to get you a quote pretty easily. I guess that is.... The finance company secured the policy for me and I never knew the name until I had to file the claim.
Good luck with it.