"Without prejudice to anyone in particular, I would have to say that if'n you scratch in the soil for your sustenance, and expect to be intelligent, chances are you cannot grasp the enormity of your situation that you are making for yourselves and your future generations."
Well I can't say much with whether 'modern' lifestyle is indeed the 'holy grail of life.' I for one use technology when it befit the necessity... I guess for me, having food on the table and 'scatching toe soil' for a living and surviving is the basic necessity of all creatures on earth... Other things can come after the belly is filled... Yes modern techniology is a double edge sword. Having technology does not mean we are all going to lead happier or contented lives, or indeed whether we are going to enjoy the lives we are leading...creature comforts excepted, I have seen how technology has actually destroyed the lives of individuals...I have seen how computer games can destroy the lives of young children, how TV can occupy the lives of children that they don't even know how to spell or use language effectively...of course other things also play a part in this ... the striving to become 'rich' and to have all the modern conveniences has most probably become a bane of modern society... if you really examine the amount of problems we are having, you might be lead to think that there is a lack of 'balance' in how the younger generation of humans take all these things for granted... but that is not to say that technology in itself is bad... it is how we use it and its impact on us now and in the future. I have heard of brain surgeons warning that they are concerned at the alarming rise of brain tumours among the general population... well not being a brain surgeon, and also knowing that these learned people have no vested interested in the mobile phone or electronic appliance industry, I can only speculate that they are genuinely concerned that somwhow there could be a corelation between the use of mobile phones and other electromagnetic devices and the rate of brain tumours. All in all, it is how we define poverty and also how we define wealth....and happiness as well....living in a 'rich' country does not necessarily mean that there is an abundance of happiness or that everybody is happy...and living in a 'poor or third world' country also doesn not mean anything...it is how individuals perceive themselves... I, for one can say that happiness is in the mind.... I have lived and studied/worked in the USA, and have also lived in a 'stone age' country, Papua New Guinea for a number of years, and have experienced the differing environments.. both countries have high crime rates, a lot of social, political and health problems, not every citizen is 'rich' or 'happy'. The 'rich' country have much the same problems as the 'poor' country. In China, as much as in India, the Phillipines, Canada, Singapore, Australia etc...however we look at things and whatever we want to conclude about whether things are 'good or 'bad' third owrld or first world, in the end, what matters is how the citizens of that country cope with living conditions and wherher they can survive...yes people some countries cannot survive without foreign aid bacause they are unable to grow and produce their own food. That is what i am saying, if you cannot grow your own food, or as you say " that if'n you scratch in the soil for your sustenance, and expect to be intelligent, chances are you cannot grasp the enormity of your situation that you are making for yourselves and your future generations." then how are you going to survive? Food is the basic stuff that we creatures survive on...nothing else matters if you cannot grow your own food or have drinking water etc... you can have all the technlogy you want, even try to use genetically modified strains of foods to produce more (I could point out to you that many scientists are concerned about the safety of GM foods, although there are many differing views on that topic, you can google that at your leisure) but in the end, long term survival is what I am concerned about. Growing food is a basic necessity... whether you are living in a 'rich' country or a 'poor, country. Intelligence is not about making the atomic bomb and destroying generations of beings...intelligence is knowing where you can get the basic necessities to survive and be happy in whatever environment you happen to live in.... By the way, I have been to many countries, both 'poor and 'rich' and have always been fascinated that even people who have 'nothing' by modern standards, are happy living in their own environment, till foreign exploiters come into their country and destroy their environment by mining or deforestation... human greed has no bounds, and ignorance then follows close by... I have also discovered that many people would not mass migrate or flee their countries if their way of life and their environment have not been destroyed by war, foreign invaders or famine.... in the end, no matter who we are, if we are to survive, food, clean water and fresh air are the basic necessities of life...whether we are living in a 'poor' or third world country or a 'rich' first world country it is who survives that matters.... no matter how rich or poor a country is, an earthquake, tsunami, or massive tornado can wipe out masses of people all at once....