Originally Posted by
Mountaincraft
BTW... What kind of epoxy did you use?
I'll be doing my drum slightly different, in that I'll be sandwiching 25 4" disks of 1.125 MDF together on a 1" CRS bar stock... I'm thinking I should use gorilla glue to glue the discs together, so that it's easy to sand off...
I think it was just good ole JB Weld. I only used three disks, and if you CNC them you should get a perfect fit in the drum.
No matter how you mount the sandpaper, IMHO I think its critical to put the whole drum in a lathe and turn it down so that it rotates with no surface movement.
I think one needs to ask how much pressure will be involved to push the wood against the drum. In the case of my sander, the answer is very little pressure. Let me explain.
The enemy of sandpaper is heat. Heat is what makes the abrasive come off as well as burning the dust and clogging the paper. If you eliminate heat buildup, the sandpaper, being so much harder than wood, lasts a very long time. The whole idea behind the velcro sander is not just a way to mount the sandpaper.
When you adjust the height of the table on mine, you do it so that the wood is just barely NOT touching the sandpaper with the motor off. Then, when you turn it on, the velcro mechanism around drum allows the sandpaper to expand slightly from centrifugal force, with the net effect of continually throwing the sandpaper against the wood but never bearing down on it. I can say that in this way the sandpaper does indeed last a very long time. In fact, the only time I've changed it over the course of year now is when errant splinters ripped the paper apart. (I am using 180 grit.) You can even stop the piece in the middle of a pass, pause for a bit, and then go on and it won't leave a mark on the wood where you stopped. Try that with just about any other sander. (If you want to take off more wood per pass, use a courser grit.)
I am not sure what a velcro mounted paper would do in a thickness sander where the pressure could build. Not sure if velcro was intended to be squished like that in the long run.
In all, I really like the way it works. With a thickness sander, you learn that you take a lot of little passes or your sandpaper is ruined. If you are going to do that anyway, why not do it in a way that conserves sandpaper? But there are good uses for one of those, too.
If you do use a velcro method, make sure you can freely turn the drum by hand because changing paper on them is a snap. You just grab a leading corner of the paper and pull the whole thing right off in one movement. To put on another, start a corner of the paper (It needs to pre-cut at the right angle) and turn the drum by hand and it will wind itself right onto the drum. Takes me less than a minute to change grit with no tools.
"72.6 per cent of all statistics are made up on the spot." - Steven Wright