You only need one of those surfaces. Take that surface and extrude the 2" needed so it would terminate where your second surface is/was. The surface will have been turned to a solid the thickness of the extrusion.
Depending on your surface, you may need to rotate it first so that your extrusion will be along the Z axis. If it is a 3D surface, the "normal" direction may not get you what you want. So, rotate the surface 90 degrees around the Y axis. Then extrude the surface along the Z axis. You can then rotate the solid back 90 degrees around the Y axis so it is aligned the way you originally had it. Unfortunately your only extrusion direction options are Normal and Z-axis. This limits the way you can get the job done, but not what you can do - just how to do it (SolidWords for instance lets you define a line and you can extrude along that line - the line can be in any funky direction).
Another option would be to use the Sweep function. Here you can define a line on the X-Y plane, and you can sweep the outline of your surface along that line. This way is a bit more complicated IMO, but I do suggest you try it so you can understand how it works. It will allow you to do MUCH more complicated solids than a simple linear extrude.
CAD, CAM, Scanning, Modelling, Machining and more. http://www.mcpii.com/3dservices.html