[bgriggs]

I am deep in the process of writing a book about DIY CNC and realized I have a bunch of topics from a bunch of different areas of CNC. I think I should narrow my focus. So what would you like to read about?

[ger21]

How about "How to setup and use a CNC router."

[bgriggs]

For those of you who voted for a getting started book:

What would you like to know more about. I have about 18 chapters so far on what I think you want but it is always better If I actually write what you want to know about.

Bill

[ww_kayak]

I've read, and am learning, a bunch of stuff. To me there seems to be two extremes when it comes to CNC books: On one hand you have the hobby wood router versions. Very easy to read, understand, and definitely get you thinking about the possibilities. On the other hand, you have the "code" books. Not really "readable", but they make perfect sense as GCode is the essence of CNC Machining. I personally love when people are able stay in "layman's terms" mode for longer while discussing the more complex topics, if that makes sense. People who really understand a subject tend dive into the details too quickly. "CNC uses GCode to run a machine... lets look at some sample code." ughh! One thing missing from other books (for me anyway) was more high level discussion of CNC principles, machines, and operators. If a computer tells a machine how to cut a part, what the hell are all those buttons for . Maybe it's just me, but I could really learn a ton about machining principles, feed rates, post processing, manual control, 2.5D, 3D, TPI, steps, CPR's, feedback loops, etc. without ever seeing a formula or a piece of code. Don't talk down to me, but stay out of the weeds longer. And this is coming from a software engineer with a math minor

[bgriggs]

I've read, and am learning, a bunch of stuff. To me there seems to be two extremes when it comes to CNC books: On one hand you have the hobby wood router versions. Very easy to read, understand, and definitely get you thinking about the possibilities. On the other hand, you have the "code" books. Not really "readable", but they make perfect sense as GCode is the essence of CNC Machining. I personally love when people are able stay in "layman's terms" mode for longer while discussing the more complex topics, if that makes sense. People who really understand a subject tend dive into the details too quickly. "CNC uses GCode to run a machine... lets look at some sample code." ughh! One thing missing from other books (for me anyway) was more high level discussion of CNC principles, machines, and operators. If a computer tells a machine how to cut a part, what the hell are all those buttons for . Maybe it's just me, but I could really learn a ton about machining principles, feed rates, post processing, manual control, 2.5D, 3D, TPI, steps, CPR's, feedback loops, etc. without ever seeing a formula or a piece of code. Don't talk down to me, but stay out of the weeds longer. And this is coming from a software engineer with a math minor

Thanks for the great feedback. Hitting the right tone for the book is one of my biggest concerns. If I make the book too simple then it might only be suitable for beginners. If I get too technical I kill off the beginners.....

I think I may have to write a beginners book and a Users book to satisfy the most people.

I'm curious if you are more interested in CNC Router operation or in metal working operations?

Bill

[bgriggs]

Thanks to everyone who responded to the poll. It looks like I was on the right track after all. Time to button up the book and get it out there.

Bill
« MAKER MOVEMENT PROJECTS

[bgriggs]

For those of you looking for some beginner information. I am posting a tutorial on my blog on how I am making a Sign. I used Vectric PhotoVCarve and Aspire (could use VCarve Pro instead) to create a V-Carved sign.

The latest post(number 6 ) deals with creating the toolpath.

CNC SIGN PROJECTS - MAKE TOOLPATHS

Bill

[Randdy]

Well friends, you did really great work by posting the tutorial about CNC. It helped me a lot as i am a new member here and i also benefited from your discussion.

[bgriggs]

Well friends, you did really great work by posting the tutorial about CNC. It helped me a lot as i am a new member here and i also benefited from your discussion.

Thanks Randdy,

Let me know if you have specific questions. I will do my best to help.

Bill

[Juaner]

I am just looking for the best router and the question that is in my mind is, whether the router size has anything to do with its performance. So I would like to read about the router.

[bgriggs]

I am just looking for the best router and the question that is in my mind is, whether the router size has anything to do with its performance. So I would like to read about the router.

Juaner,

I think I will attempt to answer you question in general terms. But I must get a clarification first. Are you referring to the Router spindle or to the CNC router table size?

Bill

[sunny_daise]

According to the above data, most of us pay much attention to the CNC price and all its functions etc..