You won't have enough down ward force to hold the wood. Once the cnc cutter hits it's depth there is no more down pressure on the wood. I have used these mats in my wood shop. if you just sit a piece of wood on one and push your finger from the side you can move it with not much force. But if you set the weight of your hand held router on the wood and then try to push it you will see it holds much better.
The design of the mats are great for what they are used for. They not only hold the wood plank for hand routing but as said above they will flex in the down ward direction to help keep your router base flat against the wood. Have you ever been using your router to round over an edge and found that you let the router tilt off the base just a little? This then causes gouge in the side of the wood. I have found that the mat will allow the wood to tilt with the router a little to help with this problem.
Thanks
Jeff Davis (HomeCNC)
http://www.homecnc.info
(Note: The opinions expressed in this post are my own and are not necessarily those of CNCzone and its management)