Originally Posted by
wizard
With round rails you have to commit to spacing the bearings further apart due to the inherent looseness of round rail bearings. That means your rails need to be longer to end up with the same working area. Now given that in many cases people using profile rails will have them too close together. So it really is a matter of what you can get away for your design and what you are making. Round rail bearings generally have more clearance compared profile bearings thus need to be spaced farther apart. Also the round rail solutions are generally not as stiff as profile rails under load.
One way to visualize this is too consider a pyramid with its base on the ground. Stable right, it resists tipping. Now imagin an upside down pyramid. Not so stable right? Many diy designs (gantry supports) are closer to an upside down pyramid than is ideal, this puts excess load on the bearings, and even profile bearings suffer though far less than round rail bearings. For round rail I’d look at triangles tha have long edge at 45 degree angle with respect to the base. With a high mounted gantry this can result in a very wide base.
The other problem with round bearings is that they can rotate some around the linear rail. So your gantry supports need to be able to resist this small freedom of movement.