The closest you can get to the mechanical properties of aluminum but without conductivity are some of the glass fiber reinforced nylons or polycarbonates. However these are the absolute b***h to machine because the glass reinforcement is so abrasive. It is also difficult to get a good surface finish and the mechanical properties are not really very close to aluminum being something like one third or less for tensile strength and less than one third for stiffness.
An open mind is a virtue...so long as all the common sense has not leaked out.