[Rance]

Has anyone every hacked a computer mouse to harvest the two optos in there for limit/home switches? I have no problem interfacing a plain ole switch to my HCNC, but don't know what extra electronics would be required for an opto. Has anyone done this? Got a schematic? Thanks.

Rance

PS: I realize that dust can be a problem with opto switches out in the open so I have a solution to that but I don't want to cloud this discussion with that issue.

[jerber]

I think you only need two resistors.
One on the emitting side that limits the current through the led.
And you'll probably need a pull-down on the receiving side.

Those resistors can be found in the mouse.
I believe most mouses use 5V ( If not all ).

I have the internals of a ball mouse laying around at work.
I'll look into it tomorrow.

[moonlighttech]

I don't have a picture of what I described to Acondit, it was just in my imagination. Perhaps I can explain it another way.

Take a pie tin, cut out a hefty portion, like you would if it was pie. Bang it flat with a hammer. Hold it between your fingers by the tip with the rounded end down. Let it swing. it only swings one way. You're holding the pivot point between your fingers.

Use the other hand and a finger to push one side so it swings. If you push the bottom an inch, it moves an inch. If you push it an inch, but half way up to your other hand, it moves the bottom 2 inches, twice as fast. Is this easier to picture?

Acondit prefers to block the light to switch. So he would just make the bottom end go between the LED and the phototransistor to block it. I prefer to let light cause the switch. So I would first block the light, then let it shine through a tiny hole to switch.

Which is better? I can't say because I think it's not how or when the sensor switches that counts. It's how fast it does it, and how fast you can detect it that counts.

[greybeard]

But I think if you use the presence of light to make the switch it is not "fail safe" ?

John

[moonlighttech]

Well, fail-safe is application specific. As far as the optical sensor is concerned, a defective LED or problem with the LED power would pass on a false "switch blocked". If that shuts down some things it's good, but other shut downs are hazardous, even lethal. It's always the action that determines if something is fail-safe, not neccessarily the state of some poor sensor.

If the phototransistor fails it depends on how it's used. With a pullup resistor to the collector the unblocked output would be around 0 volts, and if it were blocked, say 5 volts. Those conditions can be inverted by using a pull down resistor from the emitter to ground and taking the output from the emitter through a 1K resistor or buffer.

The most common scenerio's requiring fail-safe protections are power failure, human error, then component failure. Unfortunately, fail-safes also fail, I can think of several examples. It's usually through human error.

The failure mode of LEDs is an open.
The failure mode of phototransistors is an open.
The other failure mode is problably somebody else's fault!
-

[greybeard]

Well, fail-safe is application specific. As far as the optical sensor is concerned, a defective LED or problem with the LED power would pass on a false "switch blocked". If that shuts down some things it's good, but other shut downs are hazardous, even lethal. It's always the action that determines if something is fail-safe, not neccessarily the state of some poor sensor.

If the phototransistor fails it depends on how it's used. With a pullup resistor to the collector the unblocked output would be around 0 volts, and if it were blocked, say 5 volts. Those conditions can be inverted by using a pull down resistor from the emitter to ground and taking the output from the emitter through a 1K resistor or buffer.

The most common scenerio's requiring fail-safe protections are power failure, human error, then component failure. Unfortunately, fail-safes also fail, I can think of several examples. It's usually through human error.

The failure mode of LEDs is an open.
The failure mode of phototransistors is an open.
The other failure mode is problably somebody else's fault!
-

Sorry, I didn't realise it was so complex. (chair)
I thought the thread was just about using a mouse led/sensor for a limit switch.
Regards
John

[Rance]

I thought the thread was just about using a mouse led/sensor for a limit switch.
Regards
John

Actually I don't care if you ACTUALLY got it from a mouse or not, that's just easier for me. Maybe I should have titled it light activated limit/home switches.

Moonlight, thanks for the clarification(s).

[greybeard]

:wee: Irony is dead, long live irony :wee:

Regards
John

[moonlighttech]

Sorry John, I didn't mean to confuse you.

[moonlighttech]

I'm glad something worked!