TAB - the only problem with that is the setup cost -your right though, a knife handle should be strong. pressure would really improve the process, but a high-tech resin will have very good properties also. it may cost alot more over time though. For prototyping a diverse array of handles I would invest in a vacuum pump for degassing, a tub of silicone mold material, a can of good mold release, several decent mold boxes "cope & drag". I have all of this, and can make models of aproximately any reasonable properties, from metal filled epoxy faux-metal parts, to low temp melt (upto 400deg) metals. and plasticfrom very soft silicone rubber upto very hard and brittle cheapo epoxy resin.
if you dont have a good CNC machine, you will have to pay thousands per mold set.. id rather make 10 molds out of silicone if im prototyping... also, if you need real parts, www.protomold.com could be interesting... do inhouse Rapidprototyping, then out source low-count production.